By Elizabeth Baker, C’27

For generations, Sewanee’s chroniclers have amassed a virtual library of stories of “Willie Six,” the legendary Black athletic trainer who worked with Sewanee’s football team for nearly forty years in the first half of the twentieth century, in the university’s archives and databases. As the nation faced heightening racial tensions after World War II, “Willie Six” was the subject of praise in publications in the South and across the country looking for examples of the benevolence of Southern white supremacy – here was a Black man whose devoted and selfless service to the white boys of the University seemed to refute national accusations of injustice and racial violence in the South.
Far less common are stories about Willie Sims, the man behind the nickname “Six.” He lived in the segregated St. Mark’s community with his wife, Mollie. His life outside of his labor was uninteresting to the white people of Sewanee, and, unfortunately, the vast majority of local history is dictated and reported by white people. We have meager evidence of any Black life at Sewanee unassociated with work and service to the University. There has been ample reporting from the Sewanee Purple, the student newspaper, on Willie Sims’s contributions to the university, but it has been nearly impossible to find any glimpse into his personal family and community life.
As a summer intern for the Roberson Project on Slavery, Race, and Reconciliation at Sewanee, I’ve been spending substantial time in the many rabbit holes of Ancestry.com and its associated sites, looking for any crumb of information about what life looked like in the St. Mark’s community, Sewanee’s historic Black community, during the first half of the 20th century. Mentions of any family or person in St. Mark’s is a rare reward for hours of digging through census records and lease ledgers – as we work to build out a digital map of the St. Mark’s community in the mid-20th century, plotting out who lived where and when, we have begun to emphasize the search for stories about families who spent decades of their lives at Sewanee. Because of the deprioritization of Black experiences in the historical record, though, the glimpses we get of the men and women who lived and worked together under the authority of the University are scant and hard to find.
I was excited, then, to find a mention of Willie Sims, famous for his work for Sewanee, at a dinner party in the “Out of Town Notes” section of the Nashville Globe. The Globe was a Black-owned newspaper that published in the early 20th century, and now essentially serves as a database on post-Reconstruction Black social life in Tennessee. The mentioned dinner party was hosted in September 1918 by Hill Robinson of Sewanee in honor of Thurman Davis, on the occasion of his joining the military. But the meat of this clipping, and the reason I’m writing this post in the first place, is that Willie Sims is listed as a guest at the party. It was an intimate affair – there were no more than seven or eight people, which points to a certain familiarity Sims probably had either with the host, the subject of the celebrations, or the guest of honor. This is a rare example of Willie Sims the man, rather than the rubber.

Our new clip from the Nashville Globe gives us a new depth of understanding about Willie Sims’s life – there is no mention of his work, no regard for his service to the University. He is, here, a man at a party with his friends, celebrating someone about to embark on a new adventure. We know, now, that in 1918, Sims was well-known enough to gain a mention in the Globe, which could indicate some connection to the Black community in Nashville; not fame, but community We know he had a social life that did not include what he could do for white students, one that took its leisure at friends’ homes in the evening. It provokes questions that haven’t been part of the equation before: what did he do with his friends Robinson, Rankins, Davis, and Kindly? What did they talk about? Where did they most often meet, and when? Now that we can attach Sims to other men in his community, instead of the athletic program, we may venture to hope that we may someday better know what it meant to be Willie Sims, a Black man, instead of Willie Six, a symbol of white supremacy’s benevolence in Sewanee in the first half of the 20th century.
About the author:
Elizabeth Baker (C’27) is a 2024 Roberson Project summer intern from Los Angeles, California. Her work, supported by Sewanee’s Summer Undergraduate Research Fund, has focused on mapping the historic St. Mark’s community and cataloging the mythologization of Sewanee for the Locating Slavery’s Legacies database. She is majoring in Classics and Medieval Studies, and plans to attend law school. She is a member of the Interfaith House, an Americorps service member, co–president of the Sewanee Debate Union, and occasional violinist in the Sewanee Symphony Orchestra. When she’s not writing for work, she’s writing fiction on the porch of Stirling’s.













